C. G. DeLong1, J. A. Doble1, J. Miller1, E. M. Pauli1, D. I. Soybel1 1Pennsylvania State University College Of Medicine,Department Of Surgery,Hershey, PA, USA
Introduction: Recent studies suggest that chronic pain is present in 30% of patients at one year following ventral hernia repair (VHR). In these studies, chronic pain has been defined using patient-reported numeric pain scores at predetermined postoperative time points. Not addressed in this approach is the hidden burden of care for chronic post-operative pain, which would include distress and cost of ED visits, unscheduled clinic visits, additional imaging, and pain-prompted phone calls. The aim of this study was to characterize the entire course of treating postoperative pain, including all complaints of pain for up to 1 post-operative year.
Methods: We performed a retrospective medical record review of patients who underwent open repairs of complex ventral hernias, requiring at least 2 days of hospital admission, by two surgeons at an academic referral center from January 2013 through August 2015. Exclusions included laparoscopic and hybrid repairs, metastatic cancer, and inflammatory bowel disease.
Results: One hundred and seventy-seven (177) patients were included with the following profile: average age 58.1 ± 11.5 years, 56.5% female, 79.1% BMI ≥30, 67.8% ASA class ≥3, 15.3% smokers within 1 year of surgery, 21.5% diabetic, and 22.0% reporting preoperative narcotic use. Mesh was used for repair in 96% of cases and 53% of cases were for recurrent hernias. Follow-up at 90 days was 91.0% and 82.5% at 1 year. At least one outpatient complaint of pain was recorded for 51.4% of patients in the year following surgery; of these, 45.1% reported additional complaints of pain and were labeled with “ongoing pain” (Figure 1). The average pain score at 1 year for patients with ongoing pain was not markedly different compared to those not reporting ongoing pain (1.94 ± 2.86 versus 1.02 ± 2.25, p=.0522), suggesting adequacy of efforts to control pain. Of patients with ongoing pain, there was no diagnosis to explain the pain in 78.0%; of these, 75.0% initiated additional phone calls related to pain, 81.3% had additional clinic visits, 37.5% received additional, unscheduled prescriptions for pain medication, and 15.6% were referred to pain management specialists.
Conclusion: Significant resource utilization is required to assess and manage pain in the year following open VHR, even for patients who are without pain by 1 year. Patients who report pain without receiving a diagnosis frequently make additional complaints of pain and require costly resource utilization at later time points. Care management pathways in VHR patients should be designed with an emphasis on early identification, prompt treatment and ongoing monitoring of the occurrence, consequences, and costs of postoperative pain.